Join us on 12/11 for a product webinar on "Visibility, Context, and Control in Enterprise Agentic Observability"
Register now

Academic Integrity and Copyrights in the World of AI

 Min Read

The rapid adoption of artificial intelligence in classrooms, research labs, and creative workspaces is changing how students learn and how creators express themselves. But alongside these opportunities comes a renewed focus on academic integrity and copyright law, two pillars that protect fairness, creativity, and the rights of authors. Understanding both has never been more crucial, especially as AI tools become increasingly integrated into everyday academic and professional tasks.

What Is Academic Integrity?

Academic integrity refers to the principles that uphold honesty, responsibility, and fairness in learning environments. It means producing your own work, acknowledging the ideas of others, and adhering to ethical and institutional guidelines when completing assignments, conducting research, or using digital tools.

At its core, academic integrity is grounded in:

Why it Matters

Academic integrity helps maintain a learning community where assessments are meaningful and students earn credit based on their genuine effort. And beyond school, the same habits are essential in the workplace in any field that values strong ethical standards. In a world where AI can generate content instantly, upholding academic integrity is key to developing true understanding, not just output.

Cheating

Cheating occurs when a student seeks an unfair advantage by using unauthorized resources or engaging in prohibited behaviors during assignments or assessments. Examples include:

  • Bringing hidden notes or digital "cheat sheets" into exams
  • Storing answers on electronic devices for use during a test
  • Writing information on clothing, skin, or personal items
  • Collaborating with others on graded work without permission
  • Looking at someone else's exam or sharing answers in real time
  • Attempting to gain access to test materials before they are released
  • Posting or distributing course materials online without authorization
  • Using messaging tools or private forums to exchange answers

Cheating undermines the value of academic achievement and distorts the integrity of learning outcomes.

Plagiarism

Plagiarism happens when someone presents another person's work, ideas, or expressions as their own without proper acknowledgment. This includes situations such as:

Misuse of Generative Artificial Intelligence

AI tools can support learning when used thoughtfully, but misuse can quickly cross into academic dishonesty. Misuse cases include:

Information Fabrication or Falsification

Fabrication and falsification involve creating or altering information to make it appear credible or legitimate.

  • Fabrication refers to inventing data, results, or sources and presenting them as real.
  • Falsification involves manipulating research methods, data points, citations, or findings to misrepresent outcomes.

As AI tools can fabricate citations, datasets, and "facts," students must verify all information used in academic work. Using unverified AI-generated data without checking its accuracy can itself become a form of falsification.

Theft of Intellectual Property

Intellectual property theft occurs when someone takes academic or creative material without permission. Examples include:

Facilitation of Academic Dishonesty

Facilitation of academic dishonesty occurs when someone helps another person violate academic integrity rules. This may include:

  • Sharing exam questions, answers, or past assignments without instructor approval
  • Helping another student obtain unauthorized materials
  • Discussing details of an exam with students who have not taken it yet
  • Allowing others to misuse your work or your accounts on academic tools

AI complicates this area as well; passing along AI-generated answers or distributing AI-assisted solutions can also count as facilitation.

What Is Copyright?

Copyright is a legal right that protects "original works of authorship," including writing, art, music, films, photographs, and software. In the United States, copyright provides creators with exclusive rights for the duration of their life plus 70 years. These rights include the power to:

  • Create copies of the work
  • Distribute or sell those copies
  • Make derivative works
  • Display or perform the work publicly

Copyright encourages creativity by giving authors control over how their works are used. Even in an AI-enabled world, these rights still apply to human-made creations.

Can I Use Images and Text Generated by AI?

Whether you can use AI-generated content for your own purposes depends on several factors:

  • Terms of Service of the AI Tool: Some platforms place limits on how generated material can be reused.
  • Institutional or Publisher Policies: Many universities, conferences, and journals now require full disclosure when AI tools contribute to text or images.
  • Legal Considerations: AI-generated works may incorporate or approximate existing copyrighted content.

While AI-generated material itself is not copyright-protected under U.S. law, users must monitor AI output to make sure the content does not mimic or reproduce copyrighted works in an infringing way. When in doubt, attribution helps clarify how the content was created and ensures academic transparency.

Is Content Created by Generative AI Tools Copyrightable?

Current U.S. Copyright Office guidance requires human creativity for a work to qualify for protection. Because AI-generated content is produced by algorithms without direct human authorship, works created solely by AI cannot be copyrighted. Projects combining human input and AI output may be eligible for partial protection, but only the original human contributions, not the AI-generated portions, can be registered.

Creators working with AI tools must clearly distinguish their own contributions from the AI's output. Proper record-keeping can prevent confusion in future disputes or registrations.

Can Using Generative AI Infringe on Copyrighted Works?

Yes, it can. AI tools may generate content that resembles existing works or incorporates protected elements without permission. Risks include producing images or text that replicate copyrighted characters, settings, visual styles, or phrasing and generating derivative works based on copyrighted material that is recognizable or traceable.

Scholars sometimes refer to the "Snoopy problem," the challenge of avoiding the creation of copyright-infringing images with AI that has been trained on copyrighted material. Popular and distinctive characters like Snoopy are protected based on defining traits, meaning that an image doesn't have to be an exact copy of the character in the same art style as the original to violate copyright. But popular characters will naturally appear often in AI training data, so it's easy to get AI tools to create images of them.

Is Generative AI Stealing From Creators?

The debate over whether AI violates creators' rights is ongoing. Many AI models learn from large datasets that include copyrighted text, images, and audio, sometimes scraped without explicit permission. Ongoing lawsuits argue that using copyrighted works in AI training datasets is infringement, though others claim that training AI qualifies as fair use, especially when the output is transformative and not a direct reproduction. Copyright experts emphasize that rules may vary depending on exactly how the material is used, whether it's training entire models, creating custom datasets, or uploading copyrighted works into a tool for analysis.

Until courts and lawmakers provide clearer guidance, students and creators should remain cautious. Understanding the source of training data, reading platform terms, and attributing AI contributions can help uphold ethical and legal standards.

Additional Readings on AI and Copyrights

Ready to try AI Observability?
Request demo